XCritc.com Adult DVD Reviews
Porn Reviews » Adult Movie Reviews » Girl Next Door

Girl Next Door

Studio: Digital Playground » Review by Dr. Jay » Review Date: 8/4/10

XCritic's Advice: Recommended

Genre: All sex.
Director: Robby D.
Cast: Alexis Texas, Janie Summers (Heather Starlet), Charles Dera, Faye Reagan, Manuel Ferrara, Kerry Louise, Lexi Belle, James Deen, Mick Blue, Tori Black, Monique Alexander, Aletta Ocean, Scott Nails.
Must-See Girls in Cast:Alexis Texas and Tori Black.
Length: 01:49
Condoms: None.
Bonus: Two bonus points: one for condom-free sex and the second for Alexis Texas and Tori Black, both of whom are Dr. Jay's Must-See Girl recipients.


Janie Summers Girl Next Door is a five-scene all-sex movie directed by Robby D and featuring former Digital Playground contract girl Janie Summers. Janie--who, sadly in my opinion, left Digital Playground's stable not long after she joined it and is now known as Heather Starlet--appears in two scenes and has a cameo role in a third. She's a very fine performer and earns two solid "A+" scores for her scenes in this movie.

You might ask, "Why is the movie entitled Girl Next Door?" I'll tell you: I don't know! There's no plot that connects the scenes, no mention of a next-door-neighbor girl coming over to play, no playing-out of the tag line on the box, which reads: "The bush is always sweeter on the other side of the fence." Frankly, I think it would have been easy to write some connecting dialog so that all of the scenes could have been related to Janie's next-door neighbors.

Janie is supported in Girl Next Door with a very fine cast of gorgeous girls. Two of them, Alexis Texas and Tori Black, are incomparable performers and have both won Dr. Jay's Must-See Girls awards. The other girls, however, are all "A list," too. Chief among them is work-of-art Monique Alexander, but the cast also includes cute-and-adorable Lexi Belle, voluptuous and nasty Kerry Louise, freckle-faced sweetheart Faye Reagan, and drop-dead gorgeous Aletta Ocean.

One of the best things about Girl Next Door is its emphasis on group sex. Three scenes are boy/girl/girl (SO much hotter, in my mind, than boy/boy/girl) and one revolves around a boyfriend swap in which Kerry Louise and Lexi Belle get to sample each other's guy. Cover girl Janie Summers gets to participate in two of the threesomes: with Alexis Texas and with Faye Reagan.

Janie Summers Girl Next Door almost earned an exulted XCritic Pick award. In order to receive such an honor from me, a movie must score 4.5 or above in sex and overall as well as 4.0 or above in production values. This movie scored 4.45 for sex and 4.47 overall. So close, yet so far. I'd like the folks at Digital Playground to know that only a couple of things could have pushed this movie from recommended to XCritic Pick. They are: 1) there should be cunnilingus in every scene; and 2) spitting out mouthfuls of semen is disrespectful and girls should not do it. As is often the case, Scott Nails fails to eat his woman's pussy during Scene Five. Why anyone would forego drinking the sweet nectar of Aletta Ocean's pussy is beyond me. In addition, three girls made, in my opinion, the unforgivable decision to spit out semen at the end of their scenes: Lexi, Monique, and Aletta.

I'd also recommend that Digital Playground do something about its miserly selection of extras. Extras on Digital Playground DVDs seldom earn more than 2.5 stars. If DP would simply add a bonus scene (which would drive sales of the movies from which their taken), their Extras scores would rise significantly.

Overall, I enjoyed watching and writing about Girl Next Door. Janie Summers (Heather Starlet) is absolutely delightful and worth as many looks as you can give her.

Check out some photos of the girls in Girl Next Door here. Pay particular attention to the photos adorable Janie Summers! Enjoy!


Note to readers: My reviews are provided in two parts. This web page provides you with an overview of the scene's setup and action as well as my ratings for sex, video, audio, and production values. A separate Word document checklist details the foreplay activities, positions, pops, and features of each scene...as well as the calculation of each scene's ratings. The checklist for Girl Next Door can be downloaded here. You'll need a password. It's drjay2010.

Look for scenes and movies with a 4.5 or higher (A) sex rating and at least 4.0 (B) in video, audio, and production values. Those are my favorite scenes and I'm quite certain that you'll like them, too.

Scene 1

Scene Type: Boy/girl/girl threeway
Performers: Alexis Texas, Janie Summers (Heather Starlet), Charles Dera

Scene Set-up/Plot/Scenario: Dressed in the skimpiest of bikinis, gorgeous blonds Alexis Texas and Janie Summers sit on bar stools next to a shimmering indoor pool and talk about Charles Dera. Janie, who has a crush on Charles, asks Alexis if Charles thinks she's cute. Alexis doesn't think so, since Janie and Charles have been best friends for years and because Janie is Charles' girlfriend's best friend. Besides, Alexis thinks that Charles likes her instead of Janie. The girls get into a bit of a cat fight as each girl points out her own assets (Alexis' is, of course, her world-class ass while Janie points out her own pretty face). After a while, Alexis extends an olive branch of peace and the girls make up and kiss to celebrate. Just then, Charles steps into the room and is embarrassed to see his friends making out with each other. He tries to take his leave, but the girls start to chat him up. Charles soon reveals that he has just broken up with his girlfriend and, sensing a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity, the girls pounce. Immediately, Charles is naked and on his back atop a bar with his cock deep inside Janie's ravenous mouth. Meanwhile, naughty Alexis spits on, fingers, and rims Charles' lucky asshole. Hot! Charles, of course, really enjoys himself (I'd give most everything I own to be in his shoes right now, and I bet you would, too!) and exclaims, "That's it, baby, treat yourself!" Given that carte blanche, the girls go fucking nuts, inflame each other with way-nasty talk, and switch places so that both can taste his cock and his asshole. Even better, they both share his rod with their mouths and hands ("Sharing is caring," observes Charles!). Janie even deep-throats him balls deep and kisses Alexis' mouth with Charles' rod all the way down her throat. After several minutes of insanely fine slobbery fellatio, Charles observes that he's about to cum. The girls, of course, don't want that yet and Charles knows it: "I've gotta please those pussies!" So, the girls relinquish oral control of Charles' rod so that he can jump down from the bar, strip off Janie's bikini bottom, fondle and spank her cute ass cheeks, spread her pussy wide and lube it with his spit, bend her over, and fuck her furiously in doggie while pulling on her flowing blond hair. Meanwhile, naughty Alexis inflames their lust with her words. And, she strokes, finger-fucks, licks, and suckles Janie's clit and labia and makes time to suck Charles' cock using pussy-to-mouth. This segment is HOT! As the scene unfolds, Charles gets to plow Alexis pussy in mish (her clit swells large and erect), doggie (Alexis' ass-shaking fucks moves are amazing), and reverse cowgirl (her orgasm makes her body convulse!). Janie, too, gets her pussy plowed in missionary (her resultant orgasm is awesome!) and reverse cowgirl (Janie's enthusiastic and energetic moves reward her with another orgasm!). No matter what position they use, the trio's chemistry is undeniable and it shows through their words, actions, and groans. And, the girls always find ways to pleasure each other with their fingers and mouths while Charles pounds one of their cunts. In fact, the trio forms "love trains" so that one girl can eat the other while Charles pounds her vagina (Alexis makes Janie cum with her mouth!). To conclude this delightful scene, Charles jacks off into Alexis' wide-open mouth and onto her pretty face. She spits his load into Janie's mouth, kisses Janie, and then Janie swallows. This is an excellent five-star scene!

Foreplay: Mutual stripping, ass jiggling, kissing, spanking, hair pulling, handjob, double-fisted handjob, fellatio, two-girls-on-one-dick fellatio, deep-throat, stringers, balls-gobbling, finger-fucking, clit jacking, girl-on-guy rimming.
Vaginal Positions: Missionary, reverse cowgirl, standing doggie.
Anal Positions: None.
Girl cums: Repeatedly.
Pop: Open mouth; girls cumswap and swallow.

Sex rating: 5.00
Video rating: 5.00
Audio rating: 4.50
Production values rating: 4.20

What I Liked Most:

  • The girls in this scene are smoking hot. Alexis TexASS, who is one of my 2010 Must See Girls, always gives 110% in any scene in which she appears. And, her body is hotter than ever, too. Janie Summers, who is now known as Heather Starlet, is absolutely adorable in every way. She is a perfect girl-next-door...the kind you'd really like to get to know and fuck. Although I don't know exactly how stupendous it would be to fuck her, I do know how delightful she is in person because I had the great pleasure of talking with her for several hours during a Digital Playground function in January, 2010.
  • The production values are better than average. In particular, I really like the set, the scene-set up plot and delivery by the performers, and the make-up/wardrobe. I also like the supportive musical soundtrack during the scene set-up and the superb close-ups.
  • The threesome develops an incredible amount of chemistry during the scene. They ALL have the time of their lives!
  • During foreplay and pussy-to-mouth, the girls often share Charles' lucky cock. Is there anything better than having two girls worship your cock at the same time? In fact, the fellatio during this scene is insanely good!
  • Alexis eats Janie's pussy while Charles fucks it in doggie! In fact, the girls always find ways to pleasure each other while one of them gets fucked. This girl-girl action is hot!
  • Alexis Texas' ass-shaking fucking moves in doggie and reverse cowgirl are awesome.
  • Janie's high-energy and extremely enthusiastic thrusting during reverse cowgirl is must-see.
  • Both girls get to climax during the scene: Janie during mish and Alexis during reverse cowgirl.
  • The threesome forms "love trains" so that each one pleasures another at the same time. During one of these love trains, Charles and Alexis team up to finger-fuck Janie: each provides two fingers to stretch Janie's cunt wide while she squeals with delight and jacks her own clit.
  • Charles ups the girls' pleasure by spanking their butts while he fucks them.
  • Both girls' all-natural tits bounce delightfully in reaction to Charles' hard-and-deep thrusts.
  • Charles uses gobs of his spit to lubricate the in-and-out action.
  • The scene ends with an open-mouthed popshot when Charles jacks off into Alexis' wide-open mouth and onto her pretty face. She spits his load into Janie's mouth, kisses Janie, and then Janie swallows.

What Could Have Been Better:

  • I wish Janie had squirted during the scene. You can see her pussy explode in Fly Girls.
  • I wish there had been more anal pleasure during the scene. I appreciate the rimming of Charles. But a little in-and-out action--with at least a finger or two--would have been nice.

Scene 2

Scene Type: Boy/girl/girl threesome

-- sponsored by --

Performers: Faye Reagan, Janie Summers, Manuel Ferrara.

Scene Set-up/Plot/Scenario: When the scene begins, Janie Summers is in her bedroom busy getting dressed in a sexy red dress for an evening on the town with her boyfriend Manuel Ferrara, her red-headed girlfriend Faye Reagan, and Faye's blind date, a guy named Mick who Janie set up with Faye. Mick scolds Janie for getting involved in Faye's dating and Janie responds, "I remember. But, she's new in town and she hasn't gotten laid since she's been here." Janie and Manuel chat about the efficacy of blind dates and Manuel bets Janie that Faye's blind date will be a disaster: "If the blind date doesn't go well, I get to fuck your friend Faye...and you, of course." "Are you for real," responds Janie. Manuel dares: "It's time to put your money where you mouth is...or, my cock where you mouth is." Janie takes the bet: "OK, you're on!" Just then, Janie's phone rings...it's Mick backing out. Faye, just outside Janie's bedroom, overhears Janie's phone conversation and then walks, dejectedly, into the room. Manuel, sensing his big chance, approaches Faye to console her with a big hug. Meanwhile, Janie interjects her thoughts: "You know, I have an idea..." Instantly, Faye is bent over in doggie and enjoying Janie's tongue as she greedily licks her pussy and asshole. Manuel, meanwhile, kneels behind Janie and uses his tongue to rim her asshole and eat her pussy. As you might expect, Manuel also gets to sample Faye's anus and vagina with his tongue. Although Faye enjoys Manuel's oral skills, something is missing: "I don't have anything in my mouth yet!" So, after Faye rolls over onto her hack, Janie rectifies the problem by sitting on her face while Manuel continues to gorge himself on Faye's tasty twat. Of course, Faye greedily licks and tongue-fucks Janie's pretty vagina while squeezing handfuls of Janie's butt cheeks. As foreplay continues, Manuel whips out his dick and shoves it into Janie's very willing mouth for some first-class, slobbery, and deep-throat-intensive fellatio accompanied by a skillful handjob. After a while, Manuel steps back and enjoys watching the girls pleasure each other in 69. Unwilling to stay on the sidelines for long, Manuel jumps back into the fray, ravenously suckles Faye's' outstanding natural boobs, enjoys watching the girls suck each other's breasts, and then lies back on the bed to enjoy a superb two-girls-on-one-dick blowjob. Meanwhile, he gropes the girls' bodies, kisses their mouths, spanks their butts, and tugs on their pretty hair. Janie's the first to get her pussy stuffed when she climbs aboard Manuel in cowgirl, lets Faye guide his spit-lubricated dick into her vagina, inches her cunt down around his cock, and then enjoys the ride as Manuel thrusts in-and-out of her at redline speed while sharply spanking her firm and pretty ass cheeks. Meanwhile, Faye keeps Manuel's cock clean using pussy-to-mouth. And, Faye sits on--and fucks--Manuel's face, too. Later on, Manuel takes turns fucking the girls' pussies in spoon (the close-ups of his cock stretching and reaming Faye's fire bush are excellent), reverse cowgirl (Janie cums not once, but twice!), and cowgirl (Janie rims Faye's asshole while Manuel fucks Faye's pussy). Between positions, the girls share Manuel's cock using two-mouths-on-one-dick pussy-to-mouth. And, throughout the entire scene, the girls work together as a team by pleasuring each other and Manuel with their fingers, tongues, and mouths. To finish up, Manuel pounds Faye's vagina in cowgirl until he's ready to pop. In just the nick of time, he pulls out and shoots his load into Janie's open and ready mouth. The semen pours out of her mouth and onto Manuel's dick. Hating to see good cum go to waste, Faye turns around, sucks Manuel's cock dry, and slurps up his cum.

Foreplay: Mutual stripping, kissing, spitting, spanking, tit sucking and squeezing, hair pulling, handjob, fellatio, two-girls-on-one-dick fellatio, deep-throat, jaw breakers, cunnilingus, 69, finger-fucking, multiple finger-fucking, clit jacking, face fucking, guy-on-girl rimming, girl-on-guy rimming.
Vaginal Positions: Cowgirl, reverse cowgirl, spoon.
Anal Positions: None.
Girl cums: Repeatedly.
Pop: Open mouth.

Sex rating: 4.85
Video rating: 5.00
Audio rating: 4.50
Production values rating: 4.00

What I Liked Most:

  • I've already mentioned adorable Janie Summers in my review of Scene One. In this scene, she join forces with another absolutely adorable young woman, Faye Reagan. Faye has a cuter-than-cute freckled body with a rack of the absolute finest all-natural breasts you'll ever see.
  • The production values are better than average. In particular, I really like the set, the scene-set up plot and delivery by the performers, and the make-up/wardrobe. I also like the supportive musical soundtrack during the scene set-up and the superb close-ups.
  • The trio enjoys an oral "love train" during foreplay: As all three bend over in doggie, Manuel eats and rims Janie's pussy and asshole. Janie, in turn, pleasures Faye's vagina and anus with her tongue. Sweet!
  • During foreplay and pussy-to-mouth, the two girls share Manuel's humongous cock. The pussy-to-mouth, in particular, is excellent. Sweet!
  • The trio develops very nice chemistry during the scene. It ignites during foreplay and continues to support their lust throughout the rest of the scene.
  • The girls work very well as a team to pleasure each other and Manuel throughout the scene. For example, Janie gobbles Manuel's balls while he thrusts in-and-out of Faye's vagina in spoon. And, during the same spoon segment, Janie tongues Faye's clit and helps make her cum.
  • Few things in life look as fine as Faye's dangling tits whenever she kneels in doggie. Janie's perfect small and natural breasts look super fine, too, especially when she expertly rides Manuel's pistoning dick in reverse.
  • The trio forms a "love triangle." As Manuel lies on his back, Janie fucks his cock in cowgirl while Faye straddles and fucks his face. Of course, the girls kiss at the apex of the triangle!
  • Janie's moves, especially during reverse cowgirl, are definitely a sight to see! Faye does a damned nice job in cowgirl, too.
  • Faye cums when Manuel finger-fucks her pussy while he simultaneously plows Janie's cunt in cowgirl. Faye climaxes again during spoon. Manuel feeds Faye's girl juices to Janie.
  • Everybody "works" so hard that their bodies glisten with sweat.
  • Manuel takes care to please all of the girls' bodies...not just their pussies. He kisses their mouths, slaps their butts, suckles their tits, and strokes their clits, too.
  • Janie cums twice during reverse.
  • Rimming is a integral part of this scene...boy-on-girl, girl-on-girl, and girl-on-guy. Ass spanking, too, is often used to heighten the girls' pleasure.
  • Manuel pops inside Janie's mouth at the end of the scene. The semen slips out of her mouth and onto Manuel's penis. Faye gobbles it up.

What Could Have Been Better:

  • The color balance is a bit too yellow for my taste.
  • I wish Janie had squirted during the scene. You can see her pussy explode in Fly Girls.

Scene 3

Scene Type: "Boyfriend swap:" two simultaneous boy/girl couplings.
Performers: Lexi Belle, Kerry Louise, James Deen, Mick Blue.

Scene Set-up/Plot/Scenario: While sitting at a bar next to an indoor pool, James Deen and Mick Blue talk about how good it would be to swap girlfriends. In particular, Mick wants to sample James' girlfriend Kerry Louise and James wants to take Mick's girlfriend Lexi Belle for a ride. Meanwhile, the bikini-clad girls, within earshot, sit on the edge of the pool and dangle their pretty legs in the water. While the guys try to work up the courage to ask the girls to swap, the girls--who want to switch partners as much as the guys--get tired of waiting and take matters into their own hands by stripping off their tops and making out with each other while eyeing their hesitant boyfriends. Eventually, the guys work up the balls to proceed...and even swear that they will continue to be best friends after they fuck each other's girlfriend. Once they make their move, things heat up immediately as Kerry gives Mick an excellent double-fisted handjob before shoving his cock into her mouth for one of the best slobbery and gag-inducing blowjobs I've seen in a long time. Meanwhile, James eats Lexi's cunt and then she tackles his raging hard-on with her greedy mouth. Lexi even deep-throats James' big rod! The couples continue to prepare themselves for sex using numerous lust-inducing foreplay techniques (see the extensive list below) and then they move on to sex. Mick is the first to get to sample Kerry's pussy...in doggie. But, James isn't far behind as he positions Lexi on her back on the pool's deck so that he can ream her in mish. As the scene unfolds, the guys fuck the girls in numerous positions (see the longer-than-usual list below). Highlights include: Kerry's juicy pussy creaming all over Mick's cock in cowgirl; Kerry's voracious pussy-to-mouth technique; both girls' racks of Grade-A tits bouncing and dancing while they fuck; Lexi's enthusiasm ...especially when she chants "Fuck me, fuck me, fuck me!" during reverse cowgirl; James and Lexi's use of standing cowgirl (James carries Lexi aloft as she rides his pistoning cock while facing him); and the girls' sex-induced all-over sweats. Even though the two couples are in close proximity while fucking, they remain, for the most part, two couples and don't really form an everybody-fucks-everybody-else foursome. The girls do interact a bit. But the guys don't change partners. After both girls get to climax (Kerry twice and Lexi once), it's time for the guys to pop. Each guy pumps his load into his woman's mouth. Whereas Kerry respects Mick's semen by swallowing it, Lexi purposefully spits on James' cum. Pity.

Foreplay: Striptease, mutual stripping, spanking, spitting, tit squeezing, hair pulling, caressing/groping, handjob, double-fisted handjob, fellatio, deep-throat, balls gobbling, cunnilingus, finger-fucking.
Vaginal Positions: Missionary, cowgirl, reverse cowgirl, kneeling doggie, standing doggie, standing cowgirl, spoon, on-her-side.
Anal Positions: None.
Girl cums: Repeatedly.
Pop: Both girls get open-mouthed facials.

Sex rating: 4.35
Video rating: 4.50
Audio rating: 4.50
Production values rating: 4.00

What I Liked Most:

  • Kerry Louise is superb eye candy. She's voluptuous, has gorgeous tattoos, and has a delightful bejeweled pussy.
  • Lexi Belle looks adorable in this scene. In particularly enjoy seeing her nicely-groomed bush, a rarity in this bald-pussy era.
  • The production values are better than average. In particular, I really like the set, the scene-set up plot and delivery by the performers, the sweet and sexy girl-on-girl action prior to foreplay, and the make-up/wardrobe. I also like the supportive musical soundtrack during the scene set-up.
  • Kerry's oral skills are outstanding. She gives Mick incredible head during foreplay and again shows off her oral skills during voracious, slobbery, and gag-intensive pussy-to-mouth. And, her double-fisted handjob technique will leave you breathless.
  • Mick gobbles Kerry's sweet and delectable pussy between positions. There's a great deal of cunnilingus during the scene and, since I love to eat pussy, I was very pleased by Mick's actions.
  • Kerry's generous pussy creams all over Mick's cock in cowgirl.
  • Kerry is an outstanding fuck. Not only does she do more than her share of the fucking (she works herself into an body-glistening sweat), but she encourages Mick with torrents of very nasty vocabulary, ecstatic growls, and heartfelt shrieks of pleasure.
  • The girls' tits--Kerry's are huge and nicely sculpted while Lexi's are medium-sized and all-natural--are delightful when they bounce, dance, and gyrate in reaction to their own--or their guys'--moves.
  • Mick fucks Kerry's incredible, large, and spit-lubricated tits on two occasions. And, he spanks her glorious mams, too. I'd do the same it I were in his shoes...and so would you!
  • Mick takes time to eat Kerry's gorgeous cunt between positions. "That feels fucking good," coos Kerry.
  • James lifts Lexi off her feet and fucks her, while standing, in standing cowgirl. This looks really hot!
  • The girls work so fucking hard that their bodies soon become covered with a sexy sheen of sweat.
  • There's some sweet girl-girl action while each gets her pussy plowed by her guy. They kiss each other and jack each other's clits with their fingers.
  • James gently chokes Lexi's throat to increase her pleasure during mish. He also sharply spanks her ass cheeks.
  • Lexi gets to climax during cowgirl and Kerry cums twice...in mish and kneeling doggie.

What Could Have Been Better:

  • The four performers pair off and fuck as couples. I wish they had become an "everybody fucks everybody else" foursome.
  • I wish there had been some anal sex...even rimming would have been nice.
  • I wish the girls had swapped cum at the end of the scene.
  • The color balance is a bit too yellow for my taste.

What I Didn't Like:

  • Lexi Belle spits James Deen's semen out of her mouth at the end of the scene. Spitting of semen is very disrespectful, girls. Please don't do it. On the positive side, Kerry does swallow Mick's load.

Scene 4

Scene Type: Boy/girl/girl threesome.
Performers: Tori Black, Monique Alexander, Manuel Ferrara.

Scene Set-up/Plot/Scenario: While standing next to a bar in a nicely-appointed, chic, and very modern living room, hot and sexy blond Monique Alexander "makes" love to a banana by sucking it as if it were a cock. Soon, 2009 Dr. Jay's Must-See Girl Tori Black, dressed in a shorter-than-short black dress that barely covers her pussy, struts into the room and asks, "So, do I look hot...or what?" Monique says not a word and, instead, continues to blow the lucky banana while eyeing studly French tutor, Manuel Ferrara, who is reading while seated at a table across the room. Tori finally gets Monique's attention when she tells her: "Knock it off or you're gonna creep him out!' The girls get into a little verbal cat fight..."bitch"..."cum dumpster"..."fuck slut." They soon manage to agree, however, that Manuel is really hot. Yet, they'd prefer that they didn't have to take French lessons from him. Instead, Monique wishes: "I wish he'd just come over here and fuck-start my head!" Eventually, the girls hatch a plan and decide to attack him together. After the girls sit at the table with Manuel, he tells them that they're going to work on pronunciation today. He even lets them choose the words. They choose "penis." That's all it takes! In a flash, Manuel's seated on a white leather couch and enjoying the ministrations of both girls as they straddle, kiss, caress, and undress him. He, of course, takes full advantage of the situation by groping the girls' superb bodies. He takes even more advantage by positioning Monique on her back atop the couch with her legs spread wide and then moving Tori into doggie so that he can eat her pussy and rim her asshole while she, in turn, eats Monique's vagina. After spending some time munching on Tori's pussy, Manuel takes the opportunity to gorge himself on Monique's girl juice, too. Meanwhile, the girls kiss and make out. In fact, Tori even sits on Monique's face to fuck it while Manuel eats Monique. In due course, some of the girls' attention turns to Manuel's cock as they take turns sucking and stroking it. Even better, they share his rod with both of their ravenous mouths and with their talented hands! Once both girls are sure that Manuel's dick is ready for even more pleasure, Monique lies on her side and takes Manuel's rapidly thrusting cock balls-deep into her beautiful pubic-hair-crowned vagina. Meanwhile, Manuel strokes her clit with his fingers. Tori keeps herself busy during this segment by stroking and sucking Monique's sensitive clit, squeezing her beautiful tits (Monique's nipples are incredible--they're SO perky and erect!), and kissing her mouth. Tori also takes several opportunities to perform pussy-to-mouth on Manuel's dick and makes time to masturbate, too. As the scene continues, Monique sucks her juices off of Manuel's cock and then helps Tori mount and fuck Manuel in cowgirl (Tori's high-energy moves defy explanation!). Meanwhile, Monique keeps herself busy by masturbating and by spanking, kissing, and licking Tori's lust-filled flesh. Later, the trio forms a "love train" in which Manuel pounds Tori's pussy (and spanks her ass cheeks) in doggie while Tori, in turn, licks Monique's pussy. Interestingly, Manuel leans way down and helps Tori eat Monique's pussy...two tongues on one cunt! Then, Monique mounts and rides Manuel in cowgirl...her moves are awesome and so are Manuel's when he pistons in-and-out of her at redline speed. During this high-energy segment, Tori masturbates herself to orgasm. To bring the scene to an end, Manuel reams Monique in missionary (he also worships her feet with his mouth) until he's ready to spew. Then, with no time to spare, he pulls out and shoots his substantial load all over Monique's gorgeous belly as both girls watch and giggle delightfully. Tori then bends down, sucks Manuel's cock dry, slurps up semen from Monique's abdomen, and then cumswaps with Monique. Unfortunately, Monique drops the ball, so to speak, and spits the semen onto her beautiful tits. Delighted with their group tutorial, Tori exclaims, "Best French lesson I ever had." Indeed.

Foreplay: Mutual stripping, kissing, body licking, spanking, hair pulling, caressing/groping, handjob, fellatio, two-girls-on-one-fuck fellatio, stringers, cunnilingus, clit jacking, rimming.
Vaginal Positions: Missionary, cowgirl, kneeling doggie, spoon.
Anal Positions: None.
Girl cums: Repeatedly.
Pop: On Monique's belly; Tori slurps it up and cumswaps with Monique. Monique spits.

Sex rating: 4.50
Video rating: 4.50
Audio rating: 4.50
Production values rating: 4.20

What I Liked Most:

  • Tori Black, who is a 2009 Dr. Jay's Must-See Girl, gives, as always, a first-class performance. She looks damned nice in this scene, too. She's coupled with work-of-art Monique Alexander in this boy/girl/girl scene. Monique's beautifully inked body is to die for. And, her sweet and oft-erect nipples are the stuff of dreams!
  • The production values are better than average. In particular, I really like the set, the scene-set up plot and delivery by the performers, and the make-up/wardrobe. I especially like the naughty verbal banter that the girls engage in before foreplay. And, I also like the supportive musical soundtrack during the scene set-up and the superb close-ups.
  • The trio develops incendiary chemistry and works together well as a team. For example, Tori eats Monique's pussy while Manuel fucks it. And, they make both "love trains" and "love triangles" so that everybody gets pleasured at the same time. In addition, the girls really can't keep their hands and mouths off each other...no matter whose cunt is being stuffed by Manuel.
  • During foreplay and pussy-to-mouth, the two girls share Manuel's humongous cock. Sweet! Their handjob skills are first-rate, too.
  • Monique is an extremely enthusiastic fuck. She has so much fun that it's really contagious. And, she giggles with delight, too.
  • Monique's command of nasty vocabulary is commendable. She sure knows how to inflame her partners--and us--with her words!
  • Both Monique and Tori show off their world-class fucking movies in cowgirl.
  • Tori takes her pleasure into her own hands and makes herself cum while masturbating. Monique, too, serves herself while watching Manuel and Tori fuck.
  • Tori's cunt creams all over Manuel's cock during cowgirl.
  • Both Manuel and Tori lick Monique's pussy at the same time while Manuel reams Tori's pussy!
  • Every body glistens with sweat as they work hard to experience the maximum pleasure.
  • Monique climaxes during cowgirl.
  • The threesome forms "love trains" so that each one pleasures another at the same time.
  • The girls swap Manuel's semen at the end of the scene.

What Could Have Been Better:

  • I wish there had been more anal pleasure during the scene. I appreciate the rimming. But a little in-and-out action--with at least a finger or two--would have been nice.
  • The color balance is a bit too yellow for my taste.

What I Didn't Like:

  • Monique spits Manuel's semen out of her mouth at the end of the scene. Spitting of semen is very disrespectful, girls. Please don't do it.

Scene 5

Scene Type: Boy/girl/anal.
Performers: Aletta Ocean, Scott Nails.

Scene Set-up/Plot/Scenario: Sadly, Janie Summers is out of town on business on her boyfriend Scott Nails' birthday. So, she calls him from her hotel room, chats with him a bit, and then tells him that she has arranged for a surprise to be delivered to him. On cue, luscious Aletta Ocean, dressed in a miniscule yellow outfit that is sure to please, rings Scott's doorbell. "Right on time," observes Janie. 'That's your surprise! Have a happy birthday." As soon as Scott opens the door, Aletta also wishes him a happy birthday and then eagerly pushes him across his living room, shoves him onto his couch, straddles him, and kisses him greedily. Of course, Scott reacts like any red-blooded male: by fondling her drop-dead beautiful body, by pulling on her long and flowing black hair, and by groaning ecstatically. Meanwhile, Aletta unbuttons Scott's jeans, releases his rapidly-swelling dick from captivity, and gives him a very fine--and spit lubricated--blowjob (great close-ups) that's accompanied by lots of talented handjob action, too. "Holy shit!" exclaims Scott. "Ah! That's it...THAT'S IT!" Eager to get her pussy stuffed, insistent Aletta tells Scott to "Fuck me!' She then stands, removes the few scraps of cloth that do extremely little to cover her tremendous curves, straddles Scott in reverse cowgirl, and lowers her vagina down and around his swollen cock while he guides its journey into her wet hole. Then, he pistons in-and-out of her pussy with increasingly frenzied strokes as she rides him like a champion and her big enhanced tits dance joyfully. "Happy birthday!" she exclaims. Aletta is not content to simply "get fucked" during this segment. Instead, she powerfully fucks back using moves so hot and sexy that they burn up the screen! In due course, Aletta takes a brief break for pussy-to-mouth and then tells Scott: "Doggy!" Yes, ma'am! She kneels on the couch and presents her beautiful genitals to Scott for his pleasure. Of course, Scott takes full advantage of the situation and fucks her pussy fast and deep as she encourages him with naughty commentary and sexy fucking-back moves. Completely insatiable, Aletta soon asks Scott, "You want to fuck my ass?" Who in the world would say no? So, as Aletta continues to kneel in doggie, Scott slips his rod out of her pussy and inches it up her ass as she guides it with a free hand. As the scene continues to unfold, Scott gets to ream Aletta's anus in kneeling doggie, spoon, reverse cowgirl, and cowgirl (outstanding close-ups). To increase her own pleasure, Aletta even DPs her holes by multiple-finger-fucking her pussy while Scott reams her ass (great close-ups)! And, as you might expect, Aletta shows her appreciation of Scott's anus-stretching rod by giving it nasty ass-to-mouth (ATM) between positions and by having a volcanic ass-gasm in cowgirl: "I cum!" To end the scene, Scott pulls out of Aletta's ass and blasts her face and open mouth with his semen. Aletta, sadly, spits out the cum before sucking him dry. This would have been an "A-" scene if not for two things: 1) Scott never went down on Aletta's beautiful vagina to eat it; and 2) Aletta spit out Scott's cum. As a result, the scene's score drops to "C-." Pity.

Foreplay: Mutual stripping, kissing, body licking, hair pulling, handjob, fellatio, jaw breakers.
Vaginal Positions: Reverse cowgirl, kneeling doggie.
Anal Positions: Cowgirl, reverse cowgirl, kneeling doggie, spoon; DP with cock/fingers.
Girl cums: Yes, anally.
Pop: Open mouth; she spits.

Sex rating: 3.55
Video rating: 5.00
Audio rating: 4.50
Production values rating: 4.20

What I Liked Most:

  • Aletta Ocean is one of the prettiest girls in porn. Few women have prettier faces.
  • The production values are better than average. In particular, I really like the set, the scene-set up plot and delivery by the performers, and the make-up/wardrobe. Aletta's outfit is fucking amazing. In fact, I always like what she wears during her scenes. I also like the supportive musical soundtrack during the scene set-up and the superb close-ups.
  • Aletta is very insistent with Scott and gets exactly what she wants from him. She's not afraid to tell him exactly what she wants him to do and "manhandles" him on occasion, too.
  • You're going to love Aletta's blowjob technique. The tight close-ups enhance its appeal!
  • Aletta is a very enthusiastic fuck. She's not content to get fucked. Instead, she thrusts her hot and tight body up and down with frenzied strokes as she fucks the shit out of lucky Scott. Believe me, her body looks out-of-this-world good when she frantically fucks Scott...especially in reverse cowgirl.
  • Aletta's generous pussy liberally coats Scott's cock with girl juice. No lube necessary!
  • Aletta does a nice job inflaming Scott's lust--as well as ours--with her sexy Eastern-European-accented commentary and with her ecstatic moans.
  • Aletta gets so fucking hot during the scene that her body glistens with sex-induced sweat!
  • There is a real emphasis on Aletta's commodious asshole during the scene. At her request, Scott fucks her tightest hole in kneeling doggie, spoon, reverse cowgirl, and cowgirl. Yeah!
  • Aletta's gorgeous pussy gapes beautifully while Scott reams her asshole in reverse.
  • Aletta's large enhanced boobs bounce and gyrate delightfully in response to her moves as well as Scott's. Scott greatly appreciates her more-than-a-handful boobs and plays with them often while he fucks her pussy and asshole.
  • Aletta has a superb ass. It looks fucking amazing when she anally fucks Scott in cowgirl.
  • Aletta experiences a volcanic ass-gasm during anal cowgirl.

What Could Have Been Better:

  • The color balance is a bit too yellow for my taste.

What I Didn't Like:

  • There is no cunnilingus during the scene. I simply cannot comprehend guys who neglect to eat their woman's pussy during sex. What's wrong with you, Scott?
  • Aletta spits Scott's semen out of her mouth at the end of the scene. Spitting of semen is very disrespectful, girls. Please don't do it.


The DVD-9 disc I reviewed contains 5.1 Digital Surround Sound, a full-motion chapter selector, multiple chapters per sex scene, a contact information screen, a nine-minute behind-the-scenes (BTS) featurette, a manually-operated photo gallery of pictures from the movie, a three-minute self-running slide show (same photos as the photo gallery), and trailers for eight Digital Playground movies. The BTS focuses on Janie Summers (because she was the Digital Playground contract girl highlighted in this movie) and contains footage of on-set-tomfoolery; impromptu interviews of the cast members; behind-the-camera glimpses of the filming of the movie; video of the still photo shoots (you're going to love the footage of Aletta Ocean's photo shoot!); footage of Scott Nails taking forever to cum for Aletta Ocean; after-sex clean-up; and random clothed and naked shots of the girls hanging around the set, studying their lines, groping each other, and texting. This selection of extras is below average in today's marketplace. Two and one-half stars.

Final Thoughts

The best things about Girl Next Door include:
  • the emphasis on group sex. Three scenes are boy/girl/girl (SO much hotter, in my mind, than boy/boy/girl) and one revolves around a boyfriend swap in which Kerry Louise and Lexi Belle get to sample each other's guy.
  • Janie Summers, Alexis Texas, Tori Black, and Kerry Louise. All of these girls give award-worthy performances during this movie.
  • Mick Blue and Manuel Ferrara. I am really starting to appreciate Mick and identify with him. I believe that most of us guys can learn a lot from the way he fucks his women. In addition, nobody has a better sexual skills-set than Manuel Ferrara.
  • the locations and sets, which are simply gorgeous. No nondescript living rooms or ugly couches were used in the making of this movie!
  • the chemistry that develops between the couples and threesomes. Everybody has a great time during this movie.

Girl Next Door could have been better if:

  • the color balance wasn't too yellow in a couple of the scenes.
  • more emphasis had been placed on anal sex. There's lots of rimming, but only Aletta Ocean takes a cock up her ass.
  • the two couples in Scene Three (Kerry and Mick; Lexi and James) had formed into a foursome so that everybody could enjoy everybody else's bodies.

Things I didn't like about Girl Next Door include:

  • Lexi's, Monique's, and Aletta's decision to spit out their guy's semen at the end of their scenes.
  • Scott's neglect of Aletta's pussy during Scene Five. He never went down to eat her gorgeous cunt! Why?

Average sex rating: 4.45
Average video rating: 4.80
Average audio rating: 4.50
Average production values rating: 4.12
Extras rating: 2.50
Bonus point(s): 2.00
Overall rating: 4.47

X Critic Pick (4.5+ sex; 4.0+ production values; 4.5+ overall)
Highly Recommended (4.5+ sex; 4.0+ overall)
Recommended (4.0+ sex; 4.0+ overall)
Rent It (<4.00 sex; <4.00 overall)
Skip It (<3.50 sex; <4.00 overall)

Dr. Jay

[email protected]
Please report broken links to [email protected]

comments powered by Disqus
Popular Reviews

The Feral Woman
Hot Wife 2
The Preacher's Daughter
First Anal 2
Nurses Takin' On Big Dicks 3
Anal Threesomes
My Sister's Hot Friend 49
Angela Loves Men 2

Best Sellers

Featured Reviews

Get XCritic Via Email:

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner